
NBOA President and CEO
If you’ve ever looked at one of your school’s key financial metrics and wondered, “Is this good? Or do we need to improve?” you’re certainly not alone. NBOA staff members hear these kinds of questions, if not every day, than every week.
I’ve had the pleasure of watching NBOA’s data collection platform, BIIS, grow over the past nine years. Now in partnership with NAIS’s DASL, NBOA is not simply helping schools collect and benchmark their data. We’re helping leaders dig deeper into what those numbers mean for their schools, the questions they could be asking and the decisions they may need to make next.
Few people have a better view into how independent school business leaders are using data than NBOA’s senior director, research and data analysis, Elizabeth Dabney, my guest on this month’s episode of the Net Assets podcast. In addition to overseeing NBOA’s research and data analysis efforts, Elizabeth works directly with members, helping answer their questions and seeing firsthand how schools are turning data into smarter decision-making.
Jeff Shields: Since you've joined the NBOA staff, which was eight years ago, have you seen school leaders use the data differently, or are the fundamental habits and challenges really largely the same?
Elizabeth Dabney: Benchmarking is still the number one use of data among our schools, which makes a lot of sense. Each of our schools is unique, working in their own context in relation to their own missions, and sometimes it's really hard to know if you’re doing the right thing or not without having information about what others are doing. So benchmarking is still something I talk to a lot of schools about.
[In terms of emerging topics], I'm having more conversations around how data is being used with the board. Our school leaders are thinking about and ensuring that they're using information at the right level to have those strategic board conversations.
Something I’d love to see our members do is to think about data’s role in starting a conversation with the board. I always say that data is a good conversation starter — it should never be a conversation ender. That’s why I think it’s important to change your mindset from, “I need to report to the board” to “I'm going to tell them a story using data to start the conversation or decision.” Use that as a foundation to move forward.
Shields: That tallies with good governance. Ideally, boards should always be thinking about the future of the school. So they should be considering not just what the data means today, but what are the implications for the future.
Dabney: Another useful approach in board conversations is to ask questions of the data, interrogate the data. Always ask: Why does our data look this way? What decisions have we made that led us to this point? Are we able to make those connections between the decisions we make as a school and how it’s appearing in the data?
Because a lot of the data that we're looking at, especially the financial data, is backwards-looking data. It's the audit that has already been done from last fiscal year, and it's the data of things that already happened. So making those connections between making a decision, the data tells us what happened, now ask that data questions, and then the answers can help us then move into the future, look forward.
Shields: I love the phrase “interrogate the data” — that says to me that you have a lot of confidence in our data. Can you just tell us quickly why you have so much confidence in our data integrity?
Seeing the data year after year gives me a much deeper understanding of what’s changing, what those changes mean and which questions the data can help us answer.
Dabney: I, in partnership with my colleagues at NAIS, am very serious about our stewardship of this process. We make sure that we're collecting the correct data points at the correct level of usefulness with clear definitions that are relatable to all schools in various contexts and purposes. We spend a lot of time on data scrubbing, taking a human look at the data from an expert's eye, making sure that everything looks correct. There are no typos, all the data hangs together.
But I think the most important part with data quality is actually using the data. At NBOA, I’m working with it all the time, looking at trends, contributing to research reports, answering questions from schools and using the findings to inform magazine content. Seeing the data year after year gives me a much deeper understanding of what’s changing, what those changes mean and which questions the data can help us answer.
Shields: For any independent school business leader who might be listening and they want to make better use of their data starting now, what's one action you would encourage that individual to take?
Dabney: I would go back to what I mentioned at the outset of the podcast: approach the data with a researcher’s mindset. Be clear about your school’s goals, really home in on the questions you’re trying to answer, and then look to the data for those answers. It’s about going beyond the surface.
If you're looking for another concrete tip about using data, you should ask your data why three times. So if your tuition discounting rate is X, ask why. And then the answer to that question, ask why again and ask why a third time. Usually asking why three times will help get you to the root of the issue, the problem or opportunity at your school.
Shields: I love the “three whys,” and I’m going to use it myself.

Jeffrey Shields, FASAE, CAE
NBOA President and CEO
Follow NBOA President and CEO Jeff Shields on LinkedIn.


